Cheese

Amish Cheese + More Available!

Welcome to Shisler’s Cheese House, home of several high-quality products, including meats and, of course, cheeses! When you are looking for an amazing selection of Amish cheese, there are few that match our inventory. Shisler’s offers great and delicious cheeses, including the regulars, such as cheddar and swiss, to more specialized cheese, like goat cheese! Our fantastic cheese is always homemade, and tastes great! Have questions about our cheese, or anything else? Contact us today and we will get back to you!

Grid List

Showing 1–48 of 71 results

$10.19

Carolina Reaper Cheese

Carolina Reaper Cheese

Carolina Reaper Cheese is currently the hottest cheese we have to offer with up to 2.2 million Scoville units of heat!

  • Sku: 344-1
  • Availability: In Stock
$10.19

Ghost Pepper Cheese

Ghost Pepper Cheese
$10.19

Ghost Pepper Cheese

Ghost Pepper Cheese

Super Hot Ghost Pepper Cheese. 855,000 Scoville units of heat! Careful, it will sneak up on you!

  • Sku: 343
  • Availability: In Stock
$10.19

Scorpion Cheddar

Scorpion Cheddar
$10.19

Scorpion Cheddar

Scorpion Cheddar

Scorpion cheddar is currently the second hottest cheese we have to offer with 1.2 million scoville units of heat!

  • Sku: 344
  • Availability: In Stock
$25.00

Shisler’s Cheez-E-Gift Certificate

Shisler’s Cheez-E-Gift Certificate

The perfect Gift! These gift certificates can be used all at once or for multiple transactions. Four denominations available.

  • Sku: 303
  • Availability: In Stock
$34.99

White Wine Cheese Collection

White Wine Cheese Collection
  • Sku: 236
  • Availability: In Stock
$7.39

American Cheese

American Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%.

  • Sku: SKU - 19
  • Availability: In Stock
$6.99

Amish Butter Cheese

Amish Butter Cheese
$6.99

Amish Butter Cheese

Amish Butter Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: 24
  • Availability: In Stock
$14.99

Asiago Cheese

Asiago Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: 21
  • Availability: In Stock
$8.99$40.99

Baby Swiss Cheese

Baby Swiss Cheese
$8.99$40.99

Baby Swiss Cheese

Baby Swiss Cheese
  • Sku: SKU - 25
  • Availability: In Stock
$9.39

Bacon Cheese

Bacon Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: 27
  • Availability: In Stock
$12.49

Beer Cheese

Beer Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%. It is a semi-soft combination of Limburger Cheese and Brick Cheese.

  • Sku: 28
  • Availability: In Stock
$49.99

Beer Collection

Beer Collection

A pairing collection for the Beer enthusiast!

  • Sku: 238
  • Availability: In Stock
$9.09

Bermuda Onion Cheese

Bermuda Onion Cheese
$9.09

Bermuda Onion Cheese

Bermuda Onion Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: 29
  • Availability: In Stock
$6.79

Brick Cheese

Brick Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: 223
  • Availability: In Stock
$19.99

Canadian Cheddar Cheese: Fine Aged Cheddar

Canadian Cheddar Cheese: Fine Aged Cheddar
$19.99

Canadian Cheddar Cheese: Fine Aged Cheddar

Canadian Cheddar Cheese: Fine Aged Cheddar

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: 30
  • Availability: In Stock
$5.99

Chevre Goat’s Milk Cheese

Chevre Goat’s Milk Cheese

Price is per 4 Oz. package.

  • Sku: SKU - 55
  • Availability: In Stock
$6.79

Colby Cheese

Colby Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: 34
  • Availability: In Stock
$14.49

Danish Blue Cheese

Danish Blue Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: 35
  • Availability: In Stock
$6.49

Farmer’s Cheese

Farmer’s Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: SKU - 38
  • Availability: In Stock
$11.29

Garlic Cheddar

Garlic Cheddar

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: SKU - 40
  • Availability: In Stock
$26.99

Goat Cheese

Goat Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: SKU - 41
  • Availability: Out of Stock
$15.99

Gouda

Gouda

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: 42
  • Availability: In Stock
$7.49

Green Onion Cheese

Green Onion Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: 39
  • Availability: In Stock
$22.69

Gruyere Cheese

Gruyere Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: SKU - 43
  • Availability: Out of Stock
$13.59

Havarti Cheese

Havarti Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: SKU - 36
  • Availability: In Stock
$13.59

Havarti Cheese With Dill

Havarti Cheese With Dill

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: 37
  • Availability: In Stock
$7.49

Horseradish Cheddar

Horseradish Cheddar

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: SKU - 46
  • Availability: In Stock
$6.99

Horseradish Cheese

Horseradish Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: SKU - 45
  • Availability: Out of Stock
$11.99

Hot Habanero Cheddar

Hot Habanero Cheddar

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: SKU - 44
  • Availability: In Stock
$9.49

Hot Pepper Cheese

Hot Pepper Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: SKU - 47
  • Availability: In Stock
$17.99

Jarlsberg® Cheese

Jarlsberg® Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: 49
  • Availability: In Stock
$6.49

Jumping Jack

Jumping Jack

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: 50
  • Availability: In Stock
$6.99

Lacey Baby Swiss

Lacey Baby Swiss

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: SKU - 26
  • Availability: In Stock
$6.99

Lacy Swiss

Lacy Swiss
$6.99

Lacy Swiss

Lacy Swiss

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%.

  • Sku: 15
  • Availability: In Stock
$7.19

Limburger Cheese (8 oz.)

Limburger Cheese (8 oz.)

Price is per 6 oz. piece. Actual weight may vary up to 10%.

Smooth & Creamy with an intense smell & flavor

  • Sku: 52
  • Availability: In Stock
$6.99

Lucerne Cheese

Lucerne Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: 53
  • Availability: In Stock
$22.69

Manchego Cheese

Manchego Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: SKU - 54
  • Availability: In Stock
$6.79

Marble Cheese

Marble Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: SKU - 51
  • Availability: In Stock
$5.99

Mozzarella

Mozzarella

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: SKU - 56
  • Availability: In Stock
$6.79

Muenster Cheese

Muenster Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: SKU - 57
  • Availability: In Stock
$7.99

Ohio Swiss Cheese

Ohio Swiss Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%.

  • Sku: 14
  • Availability: In Stock
$7.99

Orange Cheddar

Orange Cheddar

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: 33
  • Availability: In Stock
$10.99

Parmesan

Parmesan

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: 58
  • Availability: In Stock
$6.49

Pepper Jack Cheese

Pepper Jack Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%.

  • Sku: SKU - 2
  • Availability: In Stock
$6.79

Pepperoni Cheese

Pepperoni Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%.

  • Sku: 3
  • Availability: In Stock
$6.79

Provolone

Provolone

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%.

  • Sku: SKU - 4
  • Availability: In Stock
$10.19

Raclette: Delicious French Melting Cheese (7 oz)

Raclette: Delicious French Melting Cheese (7 oz)
$10.19

Raclette: Delicious French Melting Cheese (7 oz)

Raclette: Delicious French Melting Cheese (7 oz)

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%.

  • Sku: 5
  • Availability: In Stock
$54.99

Red Wine Collection

Red Wine Collection
  • Sku: SKU - 237
  • Availability: In Stock