Cheese
Amish Cheese + More Available!
Welcome to Shisler’s Cheese House, home of several high-quality products, including meats and, of course, cheeses! When you are looking for an amazing selection of Amish cheese, there are few that match our inventory. Shisler’s offers great and delicious cheeses, including the regulars, such as cheddar and swiss, to more specialized cheese, like goat cheese! Our fantastic cheese is always homemade, and tastes great! Have questions about our cheese, or anything else? Contact us today and we will get back to you!
$10.99
Bread Cheese (8-10 oz)
Bread Cheese (8-10 oz)- Sku:
- Availability: In Stock
$7.49
Caraway Cheese
Caraway Cheese- Sku:
- Availability: In Stock
$10.19
Carolina Reaper Cheese
Carolina Reaper Cheese $10.19
Carolina Reaper Cheese
Carolina Reaper CheeseCarolina Reaper Cheese is currently the hottest cheese we have to offer with up to 2.2 million Scoville units of heat!
- Sku: 344-1
- Availability: In Stock
$10.89
Cognac Fig Goat Cheese (4.5oz)
Cognac Fig Goat Cheese (4.5oz)- Sku:
- Availability: In Stock
$12.99 – $23.79
Double Cream Gouda
Double Cream Gouda- Sku:
- Availability: In Stock
$10.19
Ghost Pepper Cheese
Ghost Pepper Cheese $10.19
Ghost Pepper Cheese
Ghost Pepper CheeseSuper Hot Ghost Pepper Cheese. 855,000 Scoville units of heat! Careful, it will sneak up on you!
- Sku: 343
- Availability: Out of Stock
$22.99
Glacier Wildfire Blue Cheese
Glacier Wildfire Blue Cheese- Sku:
- Availability: In Stock
$16.99
Jalapeno Havarti
Jalapeno Havarti- Sku:
- Availability: In Stock
$13.99
Mango Fire Cheddar Cheese
Mango Fire Cheddar Cheese- Sku:
- Availability: In Stock
$9.09
Natural Smoked Swiss Cheese
Natural Smoked Swiss Cheese- Sku:
- Availability: In Stock
$7.79
Pizza Flavored Cheese
Pizza Flavored Cheese- Sku:
- Availability: In Stock
$8.69
Plain Chevre Goat Cheese (4oz log)
Plain Chevre Goat Cheese (4oz log)- Sku:
- Availability: In Stock
$10.19
Scorpion Cheddar
Scorpion Cheddar $10.19
Scorpion Cheddar
Scorpion CheddarScorpion cheddar is currently the second hottest cheese we have to offer with 1.2 million scoville units of heat!
- Sku: 344
- Availability: In Stock
Shisler’s Cheez-E-Gift Card
Shisler’s Cheez-E-Gift CardShisler’s Cheez-E-Gift Card
Shisler’s Cheez-E-Gift CardThe perfect Gift! These gift certificates can be used all at once or for multiple transactions. Four denominations available.
- Sku: 303
- Availability: In Stock
$10.89
Sour Cherry Bourbon Goat Cheese (4.5oz)
Sour Cherry Bourbon Goat Cheese (4.5oz)- Sku:
- Availability: In Stock
$10.89
Sweet Fire Goat Cheese (4.5 oz)
Sweet Fire Goat Cheese (4.5 oz)- Sku:
- Availability: In Stock
$34.99
White Wine Cheese Collection
White Wine Cheese Collection- Sku: 236
- Availability: In Stock
$7.39
American Cheese
American Cheese- Sku: SKU - 19
- Availability: In Stock
$6.99
Amish Butter Cheese
Amish Butter Cheese- Sku: 24
- Availability: In Stock
$14.99
Asiago Cheese
Asiago Cheese- Sku: 21
- Availability: In Stock
$8.99 – $40.99
Baby Swiss Cheese
Baby Swiss Cheese- Sku: SKU - 25
- Availability: In Stock
$9.39
Bacon Cheese
Bacon Cheese- Sku: 27
- Availability: In Stock
$12.49
Beer Cheese
Beer Cheese $12.49
Beer Cheese
Beer CheesePrice is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%. It is a semi-soft combination of Limburger Cheese and Brick Cheese.
- Sku: 28
- Availability: In Stock
$49.99
Beer Collection
Beer Collection- Sku: 238
- Availability: In Stock
$9.09
Bermuda Onion Cheese
Bermuda Onion Cheese- Sku: 29
- Availability: In Stock
$6.79
Brick Cheese
Brick Cheese- Sku: 223
- Availability: In Stock
$20.99
Canadian Cheddar Cheese: Fine Aged Cheddar
Canadian Cheddar Cheese: Fine Aged Cheddar $20.99
Canadian Cheddar Cheese: Fine Aged Cheddar
Canadian Cheddar Cheese: Fine Aged CheddarPrice is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%
- Sku: 30
- Availability: In Stock
$5.99
Chevre Goat’s Milk Cheese
Chevre Goat’s Milk Cheese- Sku: SKU - 55
- Availability: Out of Stock
$6.79
Colby Cheese
Colby Cheese- Sku: 34
- Availability: In Stock
$7.39 – $14.29
Danish Blue Cheese
Danish Blue Cheese $7.39 – $14.29
Danish Blue Cheese
Danish Blue CheesePrice is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%
- Sku: 35
- Availability: In Stock
$6.49
Farmer’s Cheese
Farmer’s Cheese- Sku: SKU - 38
- Availability: In Stock
$11.29
Garlic Cheddar
Garlic Cheddar- Sku: SKU - 40
- Availability: In Stock
$26.99
Goat Cheese
Goat Cheese- Sku: SKU - 41
- Availability: In Stock
$15.99
Gouda
Gouda
$7.49
Green Onion Cheese
Green Onion Cheese- Sku: 39
- Availability: In Stock
$22.69
Gruyere Cheese
Gruyere Cheese- Sku: SKU - 43
- Availability: In Stock
$13.59
Havarti Cheese
Havarti Cheese- Sku: SKU - 36
- Availability: In Stock
$15.89
Havarti Cheese With Caraway
Havarti Cheese With Caraway $15.89
Havarti Cheese With Caraway
Havarti Cheese With CarawayPrice is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%
- Sku: 31
- Availability: In Stock
$13.59
Havarti Cheese With Dill
Havarti Cheese With Dill $13.59
Havarti Cheese With Dill
Havarti Cheese With DillPrice is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%
- Sku: 37
- Availability: In Stock
$7.49
Horseradish Cheddar
Horseradish Cheddar- Sku: SKU - 46
- Availability: In Stock
$12.89
Hot Habanero Cheddar
Hot Habanero Cheddar- Sku: SKU - 44
- Availability: In Stock
$9.49
Hot Pepper Cheese
Hot Pepper Cheese- Sku: SKU - 47
- Availability: In Stock
$17.99
Jarlsberg® Cheese
Jarlsberg® Cheese- Sku: 49
- Availability: In Stock
$6.49
Jumping Jack
Jumping Jack- Sku: 50
- Availability: In Stock
$6.99
Lacey Baby Swiss
Lacey Baby Swiss- Sku: SKU - 26
- Availability: In Stock
$6.99
Lacy Swiss
Lacy Swiss- Sku: 15
- Availability: In Stock
$7.19
Limburger Cheese (8 oz.)
Limburger Cheese (8 oz.) $7.19
Limburger Cheese (8 oz.)
Limburger Cheese (8 oz.)Price is per 6 oz. piece. Actual weight may vary up to 10%.
Smooth & Creamy with an intense smell & flavor
- Sku: 52
- Availability: In Stock
$6.99
Lucerne Cheese
Lucerne Cheese- Sku: 53
- Availability: In Stock
$22.69
Manchego Cheese
Manchego Cheese- Sku: SKU - 54
- Availability: In Stock
$6.79
Marble Cheese
Marble Cheese- Sku: SKU - 51
- Availability: In Stock
$5.99
Mozzarella
Mozzarella- Sku: SKU - 56
- Availability: In Stock
$6.79
Muenster Cheese
Muenster Cheese- Sku: SKU - 57
- Availability: In Stock
$7.99
Ohio Swiss Cheese
Ohio Swiss Cheese- Sku: 14
- Availability: In Stock
$7.99
Orange Cheddar
Orange Cheddar- Sku: 33
- Availability: In Stock
$10.99
Parmesan
Parmesan
$6.49
Pepper Jack Cheese
Pepper Jack Cheese- Sku: SKU - 2
- Availability: In Stock
$6.79
Pepperoni Cheese
Pepperoni Cheese- Sku: 3
- Availability: In Stock
$6.79
Provolone
Provolone
$22.69
Raclette: Delicious French Melting Cheese
Raclette: Delicious French Melting Cheese $22.69
Raclette: Delicious French Melting Cheese
Raclette: Delicious French Melting CheesePrice is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%.
- Sku: 5
- Availability: In Stock
$54.99
Red Wine Collection
Red Wine Collection- Sku: SKU - 237
- Availability: In Stock
$13.59
Romano Pecorino
Romano Pecorino- Sku: SKU - 6
- Availability: In Stock
$49.99
Scotch Collection
Scotch Collection- Sku: SKU - 239
- Availability: In Stock
$9.69
Sharp American Cheese
Sharp American Cheese- Sku: 23
- Availability: In Stock
$9.99
Sharp Swiss
Sharp Swiss- Sku: 16
- Availability: In Stock
$8.49
Smoked Baby Swiss
Smoked Baby Swiss- Sku: SKU - 7
- Availability: In Stock
$10.49
Smoked Bacon Cheese
Smoked Bacon Cheese- Sku: SKU - 8
- Availability: In Stock
$7.39
Smoked Cheddar Cheese
Smoked Cheddar Cheese- Sku: 9
- Availability: In Stock
$11.99
Smoked Gouda
Smoked Gouda- Sku: SKU - 10
- Availability: In Stock
$13.59
Smoked Habanero Cheddar
Smoked Habanero Cheddar $13.59
Smoked Habanero Cheddar
Smoked Habanero CheddarPrice is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%.
- Sku: 11
- Availability: In Stock
$7.39
Smoked Horseradish Cheese
Smoked Horseradish Cheese $7.39
Smoked Horseradish Cheese
Smoked Horseradish CheesePrice is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%.
- Sku: 12
- Availability: In Stock
$7.39
Smoked Hot Pepper
Smoked Hot Pepper- Sku: SKU - 13
- Availability: In Stock
$6.99
Smoked Provolone Cheese
Smoked Provolone Cheese $6.99
Smoked Provolone Cheese
Smoked Provolone CheesePrice is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%.
- Sku: SKU - 245
- Availability: In Stock
$7.39
Smoked Swiss Cheese
Smoked Swiss Cheese- Sku: 244
- Availability: In Stock
$6.79
Super Hot Pepper Cheese
Super Hot Pepper Cheese $6.79
Super Hot Pepper Cheese
Super Hot Pepper CheesePrice is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%
- Sku: SKU - 48
- Availability: In Stock
$7.49
White American Cheese
White American Cheese- Sku: 22
- Availability: In Stock
$7.99
White Cheddar
White Cheddar- Sku: SKU - 32
- Availability: In Stock
$9.09
Yogurt Cheese
Yogurt Cheese- Sku: 17
- Availability: In Stock
$9.09
Yogurt Cheese with Garlic and Herb
Yogurt Cheese with Garlic and Herb $9.09
Yogurt Cheese with Garlic and Herb
Yogurt Cheese with Garlic and HerbPrice is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%
- Sku: SKU - 61
- Availability: In Stock
$9.09
Yogurt Cheese With Jalapenos
Yogurt Cheese With Jalapenos $9.09
Yogurt Cheese With Jalapenos
Yogurt Cheese With JalapenosPrice is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%
- Sku: 62
- Availability: In Stock
$9.09
Yogurt Cheese With Vegetables
Yogurt Cheese With Vegetables $9.09
Yogurt Cheese With Vegetables
Yogurt Cheese With VegetablesPrice is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%
- Sku: SKU - 63
- Availability: In Stock
$12.39
Fresh Cheddar Cheese Curds
Fresh Cheddar Cheese Curds- Sku: 149
- Availability: In Stock
