Shop

Grid List

Showing 1–48 of 241 results

$4.10

Ben Heggy’s Extra Large Redskin Peanuts (8 Oz.)

Ben Heggy’s Extra Large Redskin Peanuts (8 Oz.)
$4.10

Ben Heggy’s Extra Large Redskin Peanuts (8 Oz.)

Ben Heggy’s Extra Large Redskin Peanuts (8 Oz.)
  • Sku: SKU - 261
  • Availability: In Stock
$8.99

Ben Heggy’s Fancy Mixed Nuts (8 Oz.)

Ben Heggy’s Fancy Mixed Nuts (8 Oz.)
  • Sku: SKU - 264
  • Availability: In Stock
$9.60

Ben Heggy’s Natural Pistachio Nuts (8 Oz.)

Ben Heggy’s Natural Pistachio Nuts (8 Oz.)
  • Sku: SKU - 262
  • Availability: In Stock
$14.05

Ben Heggy’s Roasted Pecans (8 Oz.)

Ben Heggy’s Roasted Pecans (8 Oz.)
  • Sku: SKU - 265
  • Availability: In Stock
$4.79

Ben Heggy’s Spanish Peanuts (8 Oz.)

Ben Heggy’s Spanish Peanuts (8 Oz.)
  • Sku: SKU - 260
  • Availability: In Stock
$5.99

Ben Heggy’s Special Peanuts (Hard Whites) 8 Oz.

Ben Heggy’s Special Peanuts (Hard Whites) 8 Oz.
$5.99

Ben Heggy’s Special Peanuts (Hard Whites) 8 Oz.

Ben Heggy’s Special Peanuts (Hard Whites) 8 Oz.
  • Sku: SKU - 259
  • Availability: In Stock
$8.99

Ben Heggy’s Whole Cashew Nuts (8 Oz.)

Ben Heggy’s Whole Cashew Nuts (8 Oz.)
  • Sku: SKU - 263
  • Availability: In Stock
$7.49

Carolina Reaper Cheese

Carolina Reaper Cheese

Carolina Reaper Cheese is currently the hottest cheese we have to offer with up to 2.2 million Scoville units of heat!

  • Sku: SKU - 344-1
  • Availability: In Stock
$39.99

Easter Gift Baskets

Easter Gift Baskets
  • Sku: SKU - 283
  • Availability: In Stock
$6.49

Ghost Pepper Cheese

Ghost Pepper Cheese
$6.49

Ghost Pepper Cheese

Ghost Pepper Cheese

Super Hot Ghost Pepper Cheese. 855,000 Scoville units of heat! Careful, it will sneak up on you!

  • Sku: SKU - 343
  • Availability: In Stock
$35.00

Gift Box #1: Baby Swiss Cheese

Gift Box #1: Baby Swiss Cheese
  • Sku: SKU - 20
  • Availability: In Stock
$30.00

Gift Box #2: Troyer’s Trail Bologna and Cheese

Gift Box #2: Troyer’s Trail Bologna and Cheese
$30.00

Gift Box #2: Troyer’s Trail Bologna and Cheese

Gift Box #2: Troyer’s Trail Bologna and Cheese
  • Sku: SKU - 110
  • Availability: In Stock
$35.00

Gift Box #3: Cheese Lover’s

Gift Box #3: Cheese Lover’s
  • Sku: SKU - 111
  • Availability: In Stock
$50.00

Gift Box #4: Amish Cheese and Goodies

Gift Box #4: Amish Cheese and Goodies
  • Sku: SKU - 112
  • Availability: In Stock
$60.00

Gift Box #5 – Baby Swiss Cheese and Troyer’s Trail Bologna: A Classic Amish Country Combination

Gift Box #5 – Baby Swiss Cheese and Troyer’s Trail Bologna: A Classic Amish Country Combination
$60.00

Gift Box #5 – Baby Swiss Cheese and Troyer’s Trail Bologna: A Classic Amish Country Combination

Gift Box #5 – Baby Swiss Cheese and Troyer’s Trail Bologna: A Classic Amish Country Combination
  • Sku: SKU - 113
  • Availability: In Stock
$75.00

Gift Box #6: Amish Country Sampler Gift Box

Gift Box #6: Amish Country Sampler Gift Box
$75.00

Gift Box #6: Amish Country Sampler Gift Box

Gift Box #6: Amish Country Sampler Gift Box
  • Sku: SKU - 114
  • Availability: In Stock
$100.00

Gift Box #7: Shisler’s Cheese House Deluxe Gift Box

Gift Box #7: Shisler’s Cheese House Deluxe Gift Box
$100.00

Gift Box #7: Shisler’s Cheese House Deluxe Gift Box

Gift Box #7: Shisler’s Cheese House Deluxe Gift Box
  • Sku: SKU - 114-1
  • Availability: In Stock
$24.99

Gift Box for Dad: Unique Fathers Day Gifts

Gift Box for Dad: Unique Fathers Day Gifts
$24.99

Gift Box for Dad: Unique Fathers Day Gifts

Gift Box for Dad: Unique Fathers Day Gifts
  • Sku: SKU - 268
  • Availability: In Stock
$6.49

Gourmet Chocolate Covered Pretzels

Gourmet Chocolate Covered Pretzels

Classic Animal Crackers dipped in Stefanelli’s Candies signature decadent chocolate

  • Sku: SKU - 341
  • Availability: In Stock
$12.49$16.49

Locally Made Fresh Maple Syrup

Locally Made Fresh Maple Syrup
$12.49$16.49

Locally Made Fresh Maple Syrup

Locally Made Fresh Maple Syrup
  • Sku: SKU - 276
  • Availability: In Stock
$6.09

Rolled Amish Butter

Rolled Amish Butter

Per Lb. Salted or Unsalted.

  • Sku: SKU - 235
  • Availability: In Stock
$7.49

Scorpion Cheddar

Scorpion Cheddar
$7.49

Scorpion Cheddar

Scorpion Cheddar

Scorpion cheddar is currently the second hottest cheese we have to offer with 1.2 million scoville units of heat!

  • Sku: SKU - 344
  • Availability: In Stock
$12.99

Shisler’s Cheese House Gift Mug with Heggy’s Chocolate

Shisler’s Cheese House Gift Mug with Heggy’s Chocolate
$12.99

Shisler’s Cheese House Gift Mug with Heggy’s Chocolate

Shisler’s Cheese House Gift Mug with Heggy’s Chocolate
  • Sku:
  • Availability: In Stock
$25.00

Shisler’s Cheez-E-Gift Certificate

Shisler’s Cheez-E-Gift Certificate

The perfect Gift! These gift certificates can be used all at once or for multiple transactions. Four denominations available.

  • Sku: SKU - 303
  • Availability: In Stock
$4.99

Shisler’s Private Label Fig Jam (18 Oz.)

Shisler’s Private Label Fig Jam (18 Oz.)
  • Sku: SKU - 256
  • Availability: In Stock
$3.99

Shisler’s Private Label Hot Jalapeno Mustard (8 Oz.)

Shisler’s Private Label Hot Jalapeno Mustard (8 Oz.)
$3.99

Shisler’s Private Label Hot Jalapeno Mustard (8 Oz.)

Shisler’s Private Label Hot Jalapeno Mustard (8 Oz.)
  • Sku: SKU - 157
  • Availability: In Stock
$5.49

Shisler’s Private Label Old Fashioned Apple Butter (18 Oz.)

Shisler’s Private Label Old Fashioned Apple Butter (18 Oz.)
$5.49

Shisler’s Private Label Old Fashioned Apple Butter (18 Oz.)

Shisler’s Private Label Old Fashioned Apple Butter (18 Oz.)
  • Sku: SKU - 253
  • Availability: In Stock
$5.09

Shisler’s Private Label Quince Jelly (18 Oz.)

Shisler’s Private Label Quince Jelly (18 Oz.)
$5.09

Shisler’s Private Label Quince Jelly (18 Oz.)

Shisler’s Private Label Quince Jelly (18 Oz.)
  • Sku: SKU - 254
  • Availability: In Stock
$3.99

Shisler’s Private Label Roasted Garlic Mustard (8 Oz.)

Shisler’s Private Label Roasted Garlic Mustard (8 Oz.)
$3.99

Shisler’s Private Label Roasted Garlic Mustard (8 Oz.)

Shisler’s Private Label Roasted Garlic Mustard (8 Oz.)
  • Sku: SKU - 180
  • Availability: In Stock
$3.99

Shisler’s Private Label Sweet Mustard (8 Oz.)

Shisler’s Private Label Sweet Mustard (8 Oz.)
$3.99

Shisler’s Private Label Sweet Mustard (8 Oz.)

Shisler’s Private Label Sweet Mustard (8 Oz.)
  • Sku: SKU - 179
  • Availability: In Stock
$3.49$7.49

Sponge Candy

Sponge Candy
$3.49$7.49

Sponge Candy

Sponge Candy

Sponge candy, delectable sea foam toffee covered in rich chocolate. Be careful, it’s addictive!

  • Sku: SKU - 338
  • Availability: In Stock
$49.99

Streb Meats Boneless Smoked Ham

Streb Meats Boneless Smoked Ham
  • Sku: SKU - 161
  • Availability: In Stock
$3.49

Streb Meats Fresh Cracklins’ (Pork Rinds, Chicharones) 1/2Lb.

Streb Meats Fresh Cracklins’ (Pork Rinds, Chicharones) 1/2Lb.
$3.49

Streb Meats Fresh Cracklins’ (Pork Rinds, Chicharones) 1/2Lb.

Streb Meats Fresh Cracklins’ (Pork Rinds, Chicharones) 1/2Lb.

Streb Meats Fresh Cracklins’ (Pork Rinds, Chicharones)

Not the reconstituted pork rinds you get from the local grocery store! Excellent for low-carb diets.

  • Sku:
  • Availability: In Stock
$8.49

Streb Meats Fresh Cut Smoked Bacon

Streb Meats Fresh Cut Smoked Bacon
$8.49

Streb Meats Fresh Cut Smoked Bacon

Streb Meats Fresh Cut Smoked Bacon

Price is Per Lb. Weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: SKU - 160
  • Availability: In Stock
$8.49

Streb Meats Fresh Smoked Sausage

Streb Meats Fresh Smoked Sausage
$8.49

Streb Meats Fresh Smoked Sausage

Streb Meats Fresh Smoked Sausage

Price is per Lb. Weight may vary up to 10%.

  • Sku: SKU - 163
  • Availability: In Stock
$45.00

Veteran’s Care Package

Veteran’s Care Package
  • Sku: SKU - 250
  • Availability: In Stock
$29.99

White Wine Cheese Collection

White Wine Cheese Collection
  • Sku: SKU - 236
  • Availability: In Stock
$8.75

Wild Maple Walnut Syrup

Wild Maple Walnut Syrup
  • Sku: SKU - 269
  • Availability: In Stock
$12.99

12 oz. REACH Coffee

12 oz. REACH Coffee

Specialty grade coffee from the region of Chanchamayo, Peru. Roasted in Cleveland, Ohio.

  • Sku: SKU - 306
  • Availability: In Stock
$6.49

American Cheese

American Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%.

  • Sku: SKU - 19
  • Availability: In Stock
$6.99

Amish Butter Cheese

Amish Butter Cheese
$6.99

Amish Butter Cheese

Amish Butter Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: SKU - 24
  • Availability: In Stock

Amish Wedding Fruit Butters

Amish Wedding Fruit Butters
  • Sku: SKU - 241
  • Availability: In Stock
$14.99

Asiago Cheese

Asiago Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: SKU - 21
  • Availability: In Stock
$6.49$26.49

Baby Swiss Cheese

Baby Swiss Cheese
$6.49$26.49

Baby Swiss Cheese

Baby Swiss Cheese
  • Sku: SKU - 25
  • Availability: In Stock
$7.49

Bacon Cheese

Bacon Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: SKU - 27
  • Availability: In Stock
$9.99

Beer Cheese

Beer Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%. It is a semi-soft combination of Limburger Cheese and Brick Cheese.

  • Sku: SKU - 28
  • Availability: In Stock
$45.99

Beer Collection

Beer Collection

A pairing collection for the Beer enthusiast!

  • Sku: SKU - 238
  • Availability: In Stock
$6.99

Bermuda Onion Cheese

Bermuda Onion Cheese
$6.99

Bermuda Onion Cheese

Bermuda Onion Cheese

Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary up to 10%

  • Sku: SKU - 29
  • Availability: In Stock